Posted 20 January 2010 - 01:16 AM
Brush work is normally a random process unless it is thought out beforehand. While inspiration can come during the random brushing, if you are going to plan ahead, then you'll of course have to make sure you have the tools to support your idea (let alone knowledge). I am not sure if you remember any popular places for obtaining brushes, but DeviantArt is one of them. But a work shouldn't rely solely on brushes. Re-learning the filters will be useful, but also layer blending.
I agree with you that the sig is a bit too dark. And you say "uncalibrated colors," which i would say, yeah, the sig could use more colors. For this case, i would recommend that you (re-)learn adjustment layers. Adjustment layers allow you to modify the work without making any permanent changes. While sig work may not necessarily be photography, it is still better to have the original pieces in their original state should you choose to make changes in the design.
I have not seen your previous works, so i do not know of what you were once capable of (if you indeed made sigs in the past), but this sig is at least average, and i mean that in a good way, especially if this is your first ever sig.
Text is usually one of the things that is hard to get to work right. Some take the easy route and just leave a dark area on the sig for the text, and apply some matching colors to the text. Following tutorials is good for learning new things, but try not to stick to one design, and try to be more creative. Some people after going through one tutorial stick to the same design in their sigs. That is something i would like to prevent, as it reduces the flow of creativity, regardless of how well the sig may anyway turn out to be.
I'm not sure if you are in tune with the general sig terminology, but "renders" can be used as part of the design of the sig, be it the background or some other effect. A "render" is an external image that normally takes most of the spotlight. In this case, it would be the grim reapers-like image. Normally the effects with rendres are done with filters, but they are also found to be made with brush tools and layer blending.
I'm not sure what else to say, but this should be enough to start you off on a better track.