8 replies to this topic

[deadmad7]

So, i got Photoshop CS4 and I just messed around with it for a while and made this. 

Please rate the sig on a 1/10 scale. Also, I know the text sucks, i just added that so people won't steal it. And I'm not a 'text' guy.

[deadmad7]

web_designer, on 18 June 2010 - 01:46 PM, said:

well, i don't know why all the guys here preferring the scary signatures, but since i found it scary then that means it is perfect.

i liked it even it is scary    , it blends together and the effects are fit with the overall look even the transparent border look good. so to rate this i will give you 9/10, good work deadmad, looking for more.

Wow! A 9/10! Thanks, I guess i will make the next one better, the only kind of problem i hate with it was the background, well it was made to a testy messy, so

[web_designer]

well, i don't know why all the guys here preferring the scary signatures, but since i found it scary then that means it is perfect.

i liked it even it is scary  , it blends together and the effects are fit with the overall look even the transparent border look good. so to rate this i will give you 9/10, good work deadmad, looking for more.

[web_designer]

Quote

the only kind of problem i hate with it was the background, well it was made to a testy messy, so 

well unlike you , i think what makes it special is the background, if it was on a light background color then it will look so showy and if it was on a dark background it will fade, therefore i think you chose the right background.

[deadmad7]

Tramposch, on 18 June 2010 - 02:22 PM, said:

I give it a 7/10.

To me it feels incomplete. I feel like the border you added to it takes away from some of the depth, and makes it look bad. Just a thin black border could have done, or double black bars at the top and bottom could have complimented the signature. Work on the border and depth a bit and get ready for the next SOTW!

Hey! I DID do that at first, i put two white bars on the top and bottom, but to me it didn't look good at all, it takes away part of the signature and i also liked the transparency type. Thanks for RATING!

[Tramposch]

I give it a 7/10.

To me it feels incomplete. I feel like the border you added to it takes away from some of the depth, and makes it look bad. Just a thin black border could have done, or double black bars at the top and bottom could have complimented the signature. Work on the border and depth a bit and get ready for the next SOTW!

[Tramposch]

deadmad7, on 18 June 2010 - 02:20 PM, said:

Hey! I DID do that at first, i put two white bars on the top and bottom, but to me it didn't look good at all, it takes away part of the signature and i also liked the transparency type. Thanks for RATING!

Did you try two black bars 0.0

Try it and see how it looks haha

[deadmad7]

Tramposch, on 18 June 2010 - 02:28 PM, said:

Did you try two black bars 0.0

Try it and see how it looks haha

well, i never tried that because I think it will just ruin the sig by making it too dark and besides, if it is transparent i can hide my simple text in there  

[Tramposch]

deadmad7, on 18 June 2010 - 02:30 PM, said:

well, i never tried that because I think it will just ruin the sig by making it too dark and besides, if it is transparent i can hide my simple text in there  

It could do but you never actually know without attempting it!!

Maybe a dark signature will look better with the render of choice, sometimes renders aren't meant to be turned into a figure that is no-longer dark.